The Layoff Illusion: Why Cutting People Rarely Cuts Costs
-3.png)
My neighbor’s company recently laid off 200 employees to “reduce costs.”
Three months later, they’d spent more on consultants than they saved all year.
Sound familiar? It should. Across industries, layoffs are the go-to reflex when companies hit turbulence. But the data tells a different story: layoffs often fail to deliver lasting savings, and can quietly erode a company’s financial and operational health.
Key Objectives:
The Hidden Costs of Layoffs
On paper, layoffs look like quick savings: fewer salaries, smaller payroll. But look closer, and the hidden costs start adding up fast.
1. Severance, Benefits, and Legal Costs
Between severance packages, unused vacation payouts, and COBRA health benefits, companies often spend millions up front just to make people go away.
2. Consultants and Contractors
The work doesn’t disappear when the workers do. Companies turn to consultants—who charge premium rates and lack institutional knowledge—to fill the gap. The result: higher costs, lower efficiency.
3. Overtime and Burnout
Remaining employees pick up extra work, often at overtime rates. Burnout rises, productivity falls, and the real cost per hour of output climbs.
4. Rehiring and Retraining
When business rebounds (and it always does), companies must rehire. Recruiting and onboarding new talent can cost 50–200% of an employee’s annual salary. That “cost reduction” suddenly looks more like a loan.
The Human Side: Survivor Syndrome
After a layoff, the people left behind often experience what psychologists call survivor syndrome—a mix of guilt, anxiety, and mistrust.
-
Morale plummets. Employees see layoffs as betrayal.
-
Trust erodes. Risk-taking and creativity decline.
-
Turnover spikes. The most talented survivors—the ones with options—often leave first.
According to research by Wayne Cascio (University of Colorado), Jeffrey Pfeffer (Stanford University) and Peter Cappelli (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania), companies that rely on layoffs don’t outperform their peers. In fact, their stock prices often lag behind competitors for years.
What the Research Says
Academic research overwhelmingly confirms that layoffs are an ineffective long-term strategy:
Wayne F. Cascio (University of Colorado): Professor Cascio is arguably the leading researcher on the financial and human consequences of downsizing.
- Key Finding: In his extensive research, he has repeatedly found that companies that aggressively downsize do not outperform companies that use other means to manage costs. In fact, their stock prices often lag behind their competitors in the years following a layoff.
- Relevant Work: His book, "Responsible Restructuring: Creative and Profitable Alternatives to Layoffs," is a cornerstone text. He's published numerous articles in journals like the Academy of Management Executive detailing the negative stock market reactions and operational disruptions following layoff announcements.
-
- Key Finding: He emphasizes that layoffs break the psychological contract between employer and employee, leading to a host of negative long-term consequences that damage a company's ability to innovate and compete. He advocates for managing people as assets, not costs.
- Relevant Work: His book, "The Human Equation: Building Profits by Putting People First," synthesizes much of the evidence against conventional "tough-minded" management practices like layoffs.
-
- Key Finding: Cappelli often highlights the shortsightedness of laying off skilled workers only to re-hire for the same skills a short time later in a tighter labor market, a costly cycle he calls the "talent management problem."
Their conclusion?
Layoffs are a blunt instrument that often inflict more damage than they prevent.
Smarter CFOs Know: Cut Costs, Not Muscle
Forward-thinking CFOs and CHROs know the real trick isn’t cutting people—it’s cutting smarter. Here’s how the best do it:
Because as my neighbor’s story shows, if your “cost savings” strategy ends with higher consulting bills, it’s not strategy—it’s expensive denial.
Watch: Smarter CFOs in Action
Watch Susanna explain how CFOs are cutting costs without cutting muscle.
Learn how organizations are blending automation, AI, and contingent talent to stay agile without sacrificing people or performance.
FAQs: Smarter Cost-Cutting Strategies
1. Do layoffs ever work as a cost-cutting strategy?
In rare cases—like total restructuring or bankruptcy—they can. But for most profitable or stable companies, layoffs offer short-term relief at the cost of long-term competitiveness, morale, and innovation.
2. What’s the financial impact of “survivor syndrome”?
Studies show a 20–40% drop in productivity after major layoffs. Morale issues lead to absenteeism, disengagement, and turnover, which can quietly drain millions from your bottom line.
3. How can companies reduce costs without layoffs?
Options include hiring freezes, reduced workweeks, voluntary exits, redeployment, and cutting operational waste. Partnering with an Employer of Record (EOR) or contingent workforce provider like TCWGlobal can also flex staffing without permanent headcount cuts.
4. Why do companies still choose layoffs if they don’t work?
Because they’re visible, fast, and look decisive to shareholders. Unfortunately, they’re also a form of short-term theater—appealing on earnings calls, but damaging in the quarters that follow.
5. What’s a smarter workforce model for uncertain times?
Modern CFOs are blending AI-driven efficiency, contingent workforce models, and EOR partnerships to stay lean, flexible, and compliant—without the human and financial fallout of layoffs.
Want to learn more we have blogs, podcasts, videos, and more for you!
Final Thought
Layoffs might look like discipline on a balance sheet, but in reality, they often signal panic. The best CFOs know that resilience isn’t built by cutting muscle, it’s built by rethinking how work gets done.
In short: smart companies don’t just survive downturns, they redesign intelligently, without breaking what makes them strong.
Need Help?
Need help managing your contingent workforce? Contact TCWGlobal today to learn more.
Whether you need expertise in Employer of Record (EOR) services, Managed Service Provider (MSP) solutions, or Vendor Management Systems (VMS), our team is equipped to support your business needs. We specialize in addressing worker misclassification, offering comprehensive payroll solutions, and managing global payroll intricacies.
From remote workforce management to workforce compliance, and from international hiring to employee benefits administration, TCWGlobal has the experience and resources to streamline your HR functions. Our services also include HR outsourcing, talent acquisition, freelancer management, and contractor compliance, ensuring seamless cross-border employment and adherence to labor laws.
We help you navigate employment contracts, tax compliance, workforce flexibility, and risk mitigation, all tailored to your unique business requirements. Contact us today at tcwglobal.com or email us at hello@tcwglobal.com to discover how we can help your organization thrive in today's dynamic work environment. Let TCWGlobal assist with all your payrolling needs!
